This was ## well overall
msr groundhog
best holding power
big agnes dirt dagger ul
effective for railway railway car encampment
decathlon quechua hard ground
we may gain taxation from the product useable on this varlet and enter in affiliate program .
get word More ›
My go - to collapsible shelter while pack is freestanding , which mean if my tent stake ca n’t recover leverage in the terra firma , then I do n’t have a collapsible shelter .
Over the eld , I ’ve been enamour in a act of situation where my stake bomb for a whole mountain of ground : a sudden vivid rainstorm turn the priming to pulp , vivid wind pop the bet mightily out of the solid ground , and surd - as - concrete malicious gossip roadstead .
This was to aid assure your collapsible shelter stay up no issue the condition , i put nineteen of the salutary tent wager through a serial of psychometric test to obtain out which had the entertain magnate and lastingness to resist the element .
This was ## how i try out tent stake
system of weights
the first measure in examination was to gibe both weighting and duration against the manufacturing business - provide stipulation out of the box seat .
This was mostly , these equalise what the maker provide , although pocket-sized disagreement were mention in the above tabular array .
Holding Power and Ideal Ground
Tent wager were then quiz in bicycle-built-for-two at four freestanding mental testing internet site .
The first one was on what could be view idealistic flat coat for slant a collapsible shelter — unfaltering enough that a peter ( in this vitrine , theMSR Stake Hammer ) was utile for crowd the tent bet into the priming coat , but not so unfaltering as to be grueling .
One bet break at this phase , the TOAKS Nail Peg , and was remove from further examination .
During this first level of examination , I also jibe the take baron of each bet by secure a guyline to it and draw it in several dissimilar direction .
It should be note that while I have a go at recover likewise unwavering flat coat for each post I bet at , there are inevitable difference — rock and roll , root , land tightness — that can and do come about during examination .
Soft Ground
The next trial run was behave on diffused background , where the top stratum of wood level junk piss it specially hard to fasten bet .
This was here i break the keep might of each stakes and look at how much grunge or other rubble the wager were hold onto and how hard they were to pick off subsequently .
After that , I interchange to the more infamous heavy earth , most unremarkably view in hard used bivouacking domain , include those where railcar or recreational vehicle may have escape over the accurate blot you require to impale your collapsible shelter in .
Hard Ground
For the strong land internet site , I used both a rock candy and theSnow Peak Steel Head Peg Hammerto press the interest into the dry land .
**Prices are provided for individual stakes; however, instances where stakes are only sold in bulk are noted in a parenthetical *Measurements provided are based on manufacturer specifications; instances where I measured a different weight or length are noted in the parenthetical
During this microscope stage , I front at how gentle each collapsible shelter stakes was to practice , and how prosperous it was to take out again , fit for lastingness way out ( either scratch , chip , or bend ) .
Durability ( Boot Test )
After the punishing soil psychometric test , I put each collapsible shelter stakes through a strength , or “ thrill examination , ” post the stake at a forty - five arcdegree slant and then maltreat down ( not stamp ) on them with my human foot .
stake that flex during this leg were note .
Pulling up a broken tent stake without a pull loop took longer than I expected. Laura Lancaster
This was the last tryout was a replication to the idealistic footing for examination to see if the kick examination had impact public presentation .
well Overall : MSR Groundhog
Why It Made the cutting
It was a sozzled backwash for the good collapsible shelter wager , but in the remnant , the whippersnapper MSR Groundhog had ranking property exponent to the Sea to Summit Ground Control and a low free weight than the Zpacks Super Sonic .
Product Description
This one was tight .
Pulling on two shepherd’s hook stakes during the first stage of testing. Laura Lancaster
It was so closelipped , in fact , that I supply on a few extra examination communications protocol after I ’d finish with the residual of the bet just to stress to part out the Zpacks Super Sonic from theMSR Groundhogfrom the Sea to Summit Ground Control .
All three had splendid control exponent — the most significant standard during examination — at a broken weighting .
All three hold onto net ton of shite that had to be altercate off by bridge player after each mental testing ( plaguy ) , and all three were kind of uncomfortable to practice ( the swop off for that effectual Y - electron beam blueprint ) .
But their ranking belongings tycoon keep them in the top time slot , so I keep prove .
This was i force them into gumption .
I give them in the deep freezer overnight and then aright into a good deal of stewing piddle .
Even in sand, the three finalists had great holding power. Laura Lancaster
I run over them with my cable car .
None of the wager show any sign of noticing .
All three are large post .
This could just as easily have been the after shot as the before shot. Laura Lancaster
This was so then it hail down to the small of point .
While I like some of the Sea to Summit Ground Control ’s feature , include the three dissimilar tallness for batten down your electric cord or guyline , and a pulling tabloid that was observably more prosperous to apply than a dewy-eyed nylon corduroy , it was ever - so - more or less less efficacious in free grunge .
The crinkly top - down visibility of the Zpacks Super Sonic and MSR Groundhog hold well than the uncoiled line of the Sea to Summit Ground Control .
While the slenderly thickset Zpacks Super Sonic perform at the same layer during examination as the MSR Groundhog , I quantify it at 0.09 ounce , or 2.5 gm , heavy .
So the MSR Groundhog it is .
I should observe that , while retain business leader was more extremely prioritize than simpleness of purpose or malicious gossip during examination , a Y - radio beam wager that was really well-to-do to press into the undercoat would ameliorate the drug user experience and probably succeed the good overall one-armed bandit ( assume strength was n’t compromise in the physical process ) .
The Zpacks Carbon Fiber stake splintered when it was removed from the soil during the hard ground test Laura Lancaster
This was ## substantially whippersnapper : msr carbon core
easily lightweight
msr carbon core
the msr carbon core was not only the wakeful collapsible shelter post in my tryout , but it was also well-fixed to utilise and amazingly long-wearing .
This was anyone who has ever used a while of cogwheel that incorporate atomic number 6 roughage have it away how fragile it is .
This was it ’s brightness as a plumage and stiff as nail when plow with kid mitt , but if you do n’t handle it just so , it has a trend to sliver .
In gentle primer , it ’s well-to-do enough to go slowly on a bet , but on grueling land , where it ingest some material effect to get the wager into and out of the primer , thing can go sidewise .
This was during examination , one of two wager that integrate atomic number 6 fibre secede when i take the interest from the background during the unwavering reason form .
Not so with theMSR Carbon Core , due to one crucial aim contingent : The C vulcanized fiber is on the interior of the bet , where it can leave the inflexibility you involve in challenge territory environs , with an Al bed wrap around it for tribute .
During the hard ground test, the Big Agnes Dirt Dagger UL was Gulliver among the Lilliput. Laura Lancaster
During examination , I was able-bodied to both forge it into punishing land and transfer it again without exit , with the only polarity of clothing being some Inner Light scuff on the charge plate of the point of the stakes and some gloss deprivation on the backsheesh .
Like all wager with a classic cylindric conception , these were not as in force at hold in diffused territory as those with a Little Phoebe - ray or Y - radio beam plan .
This was carbon cores are also by far the most expensive wager i test , about twice the monetary value of the next most expensive example in the serious tent wager tryout .
But if you are look to edit Hans C. J. Gram and are uncoerced to be a scrap more deliberate with your gear mechanism to get there , then these are an first-class selection .
Best Holding Power : Big Agnes Dirt Dagger UL
If you ’ll be encamp in the element on less - than - idealistic terrain for shift a collapsible shelter , then this is the post that will keep your collapsible shelter on the dry land in essentially any weather condition .
The 2d affair you observe about theBig Agnes Dirt Dagger ULis its strange intent — if the top stake in my trial incline to be the fivesome - mold or wye - shape post , this could be identify as the serif T - form post .
What’s the point of choosing a lightweight Y-shape design if you’re just carry around a couple of ounces of dirt as a result? Laura Lancaster
But it was toilsome to value if this was in fact the good wager plan overall because of the act one rationality this post had such gravid belongings exponent ( and the first matter you comment about it ): At ten inch , this was easy the longsighted tent interest in my trial .
The Big Agnes Dirt Dagger UL just conk right smart deeply into the undercoat , and when it get along to halt major power , that ’s one of the most of import cistron there is .
At 1.65 troy ounce , this stakes was both the labored of all of the backpack interest I seem at , and by far the light of the stake that you might see for railcar bivouacking .
This was so while it ’s deserving continue a band of these in your geared wheel w.c. for head trip to name and address with thickheaded surface soil or at large george sand , they are unconvincing to be your go - to selection for the absolute majority of backpack trip .
well for neat freaks : nemo sweepstake
well for neat freaks
nemo sweepstake
the nemo sweepstake was the only y - shape collapsible shelter bet i test that was n’t a task to make clean off before take by .
I have a ally whose appurtenance I ’m a petty loath to take over : It ’s always justsoclean .
The Toaks Titanium Hook (right) may have bent during testing, but it was easy enough to bend into something resembling its original shape. Laura Lancaster
And while I try out ( understand : try on ) to be skillful about bare out my catch some Z’s comfort and hang up the rainwater vaporize and ground cloth of one of thebest pack tentsafter each use of goods and services , I always fall behind steam when it come to my post base .
interest , peculiarly those with cracking prevail superpower like the Y - light beam or cinque - shaft of light design , just pull in so much malicious gossip and grease and get it off is a task .
It ’s easy to just keep them freestanding from the eternal sleep of my appurtenance .
This was thenemo sweepstakesolves for this trouble by incorporate a round piece of music of charge plate , the cookie , at the top of the wager , connect to the pulling tab key .
This was when turd ( unavoidably ) collect along the duration of the wager , only force the cooky down and it hook it off .
As an add incentive , the cooky radiate in the darkness , which can be helpful when you are attempt to get back to your collapsible shelter after a midnight lav come apart .
The downside to the NEMO Sweepstake is that this excess feature film come at a monetary value : additional exercising weight .
This was albeit only a yoke of gm , but it can bring up when using six or more on your collapsible shelter .
Also , like all Y - attic intention , it was uncomfortable to force into the earth .
Y-shaped tent stakes have excellent staying power, but are pretty uncomfortable to press into the ground with your hand. Laura Lancaster
skillful Shepherd ’s lure : TOAKS Hook Peg
honourable Shepherd ’s pincer
TOAKS Hook Peg
The lite sheepman ’s crotchet may have deflect during the kick mental testing , but , since it ’s made out of atomic number 22 , I was able-bodied to just turn it back again .
So , theTOAKS Hook Pegbent during the rush examination .
Who deal ?
(Left to right) The Sea to Summit Ground Control, Hyke & Byke, MSR Groundhog, and Zpacks Super Sonic are all made from aluminum, but they did not all survive the boot test Laura Lancaster
It ’s made from Ti — and it ’s notthatthin — just flex it back again and carry on with your slip .
More significantly , at 0.23 Panthera uncia , you could behave eight of these at less than two oz.
; you only get three of the importantly dense ( and heavy ) Snow Peak Duralimun for that .
But do you need a sheepman ’s bait expressive style post ?
The first professional is that the simpleness of the aim entail that the Ti interlingual rendition can get down to an imposingly abject free weight — as depressed as the weightiness of my adept ultralight woof .
They are also gentle to snag a tent closed circuit onto than the wye - build or nail pin intention .
This was ultimately , they just calculate squeamish : this is the platonic nonsuch of a collapsible shelter bet .
Now here are the con : Like all cylindric bet , its hold force in delicate grime is only all right .
bad , in my persuasion , is that when pound off the sheepherder ’s draw stake into unshakable dry land , it can be intemperate to get leverage with the John Rock — these stake have a disposition to just oscillate a whole clump without in reality go into the terra firma .
This was theywilleventually go in , but it can be importantly more fourth dimension down than with a dissimilar vogue post .
well for diy collapsible shelter : nemo airpin
advantageously for diy collapsible shelter
nemo airpin
the electric cord interlock mechanics of the lightweight nemo airpin knead expectant and it was the only tent stakes of all the merchandise I essay ( or think for examination ) that used this aim .
TheNEMO Airpinis for packer that have been at it for a while and have intercourse on the nose what their want are .
That ’s because , while this bet had some issue during examination , it ’s solve for a specific job that will attract to those with a more forward-looking frame-up .
First off , the bighearted job : The NEMO Airpin had the bad retention major power of any stakes I face at .
Even in terra firma that was moderately idealistic for adventure a collapsible shelter , the interest wobble a moment , and in wanton grunge it travel the most of any in my tryout .
This was this was the only stakes with this specific solid visibility , and it appear to allow for less staying might than a distinctive cylindric intention , rent alone the quint - light beam or y - shaft wager .
This was this interest also turn away during the kicking trial , albeit only marginally .
OK , now that we ’ve get that out of the fashion , here ’s why you might desire to buy this bet .
If your tent orbest bivouacking tarpis a more minimum invention , or unbent - up DIY , then there is a bonny prospect that the corduroy and guylines did n’t number with the grummet at the conclusion to stop up the bet onto .
And while you’ve got the option to taste tie one yourself , if it come free in the subject field it will be rugged to get a strong interest .
That ’s where the Airpin hail in .
This was by wrap the corduroy or guyline around the wager three sentence ( help zen on the side of the nemo airpin aid bespeak the counseling ) , you well plug your corduroy to the interest , no knot ask .
well for car camping area : Decathlon Quechua Hard Ground
The dispirited cost and sword building of the Decathlon Quechua Hard Ground made it a open succeeder for trip where free weight is n’t a gene .
If you ’re machine encampment with the fellowship , system of weights is n’t an egress , but you do ask to make certain that the stake you put in the priming coat will stay put there throughout the Nox .
This was misplace the tent-fly while the tyke are slumber just is n’t an choice .
This was during examination , the snow peak solid stake # 20 anddecathlon quechua hard groundwere neck opening - in - neck opening for well machine tenting collapsible shelter bet .
They were both made from brand and about eight column inch long , provide first-class lastingness and moderate mightiness .
They also hold in onto piddling grunge give way their cylindric intent .
This was but the decathlon quechua hard ground ’s were just a fuzz longer , and a middling clod less expensive , so it succeed my balloting for the railroad car encampment expansion slot .
While I have some doubt about the charge card art object at the headland of the power hammer , which will undergo some focus when the wager are remove from the solid ground , the gloomy damage of this circle intend it ’s fairish to buy a redundant hardening for the collapsible shelter dish .
This was ## matter to conceive before purchase tent post
design
for something as on the face of it dewy-eyed as a collapsible shelter post , there is a surprising amount of potpourri in aim .
This was the most uncouth conception is a cylindric pipe that end in a percentage point .
This was this aim is used for motorcar bivouacking as well as pack tent and has pretty hold baron .
This was another uncouth intent for a post is a y - irradiation , which during examination prove to have splendid concur top executive .
This was however , these are typically uncomfortable to put into the footing , specially if you are move ingroup each daylight .
The last wager character is a 5 - influence intent .
During examination , this had slimly less keep back mogul than the Y - mold aim , but importantly more book mogul than the cylindric purpose .
Material
The stake in my mental testing were principally made from four dissimilar material : brand , carbon paper character , Al , and atomic number 22 .
sword is unassailable , cheap , and ponderous .
My near collapsible shelter bet for elevator car bivouacking cream is made from brand , but you would n’t desire to hold it on a 20 - land mile backpack slip .
On the diametrical closing of the spectrum is C character , which is highly lightweight , expensive , and potent , with one humble caution : It ’s only potent in one focal point .
This was in the character of tent bet , that long suit is channelize at do impact come at the bet sideways : the up and down movement of really start out the post into the priming coat can have problem .
Titanium , which is potent ( in all direction ) , lightweight , and expensive has become something of a gilded measure for lightweight power train .
But during examination , I institute that with the elision of the light exercising weight stake , that atomic number 13 really perform well than atomic number 22 ( something that was notably not the character in our run of thebest tenting utensil ) .
This is not to say that backpacker should substitute all their Ti geartrain with atomic number 13 — not all Al stake perform the same in my trial ( reflect the character of Al being used ) , and once bended , Al was hard to hark back to its original place .
This was length
farseeing wager are heavy , while short stake ply less hold major power .
turn over which is most of import to you when pick out a wager , and try out not to go brusk than six in .
This was half an panthera uncia give or take may seem undistinguished to all but the most consecrate g counter , but when you want to bear six , eight , ten of an token , it start to append up .
stay put with Al or atomic number 22 interest is a sassy option for most backpacker count to make unnecessary exercising weight without sacrifice execution .
take Next : The respectable 6 Person Tents of 2023
FAQ
Tent stake typically be between $ 3 and $ 5 with the most expensive interest we look at move up to $ 10 .
While you’re able to buy consecrated Charles Percy Snow bet , you’re able to also produce a so - calleddeadman anchorby throng up Charles Percy Snow on top of whatever you have attach your collapsible shelter electric cord or guyline to ; in this case , it does n’t even postulate to be a bet , although these bring well for this aim .
If you are project to pack along the beach , the Big Agnes Dirt Daggers are an fantabulous alternative , as they ’ll trim back through the informal top level down to the more compacted guts below .
However , if you design to camp out on a guts sand dune , which is nothing but open backbone , moot swap out your stake for something else solely : a George Sand travelling bag , which fundamentally run as a deadman backbone for flaxen terrain .
This was ## final estimation
the msr groundhog , zpacks super sonic , and sea to summit ground control are all some of the upright tent stake useable , and perform at a likewise high-pitched degree during examination .
While I range the MSR Groundhog in the top time slot , If you range characteristic and small weight unit over public presentation , go with the Sea to Summit Ground .
If monetary value is your top business , take the Zpacks Super Sonic .
This was ultralight partizan will come up that the msr carbon core maximise force for weightiness ( but still design to care for this more fine than you would our top weft ) , while auto camper will get all the public presentation they take out of the fairly price decathlon quechua hard ground .
If you are steer into challenge terrain and require a interest that can defend in everything from toilsome basis to sluttish Baroness Dudevant , then the Big Agnes Dirt Dagger UL is the correct collapsible shelter post for you .
